Answers to the Top 8 Medicare Supplement Questions

Are you wondering if you need Medicare Supplement insurance or if you’re required by law to have it? Find out these and other supplemental Medicare insurance answers.

Like spackle on a wall or a filling on a tooth, Medicare Supplement insurance, a.k.a., Medigap, exists to fill in any potential gaps in coverage. In the case of supplemental Medicare insurance, it covers the difference between what is paid for by original Medicare and the overall cost of the health care treatment provided. Sold by private insurers, supplemental health insurance helps with charges like copays, deductibles, and coinsurance.

Erin Bueltel, a product specialist at Medico Insurance Company, answers the most common Medicare Supplement insurance questions, including who is eligible, how to shop for it, and the real difference between Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans.

1. Who is eligible for Medicare Supplement insurance?

Most states — 33 of the 50 — require insurance companies to offer supplemental insurance to those under 65 on Medicare disability.
If you’re 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part A and Part B, you can apply for Medicare Supplement insurance. An open enrollment period occurs within 6 months of obtaining Medicare Part B, and you can apply for a Medicare Supplement policy without having to answer health questions.
Companies can deny you Medicare Supplement insurance coverage, depending on pre-existing conditions and other considerations, if you apply outside of the 6-month window, so be sure to ask your insurer about what qualifications make someone eligible for their specific Medicare Supplement insurance.
“If you are not in your open enrollment period or are not eligible for guaranteed issue, you will have to answer health questions in order to qualify. Those individuals within their open enrollment period or eligible for guaranteed issue would not need to answer the health questions to qualify,” says Bueltel.

Discover the Difference Between Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement Plans

2. Is Medicare Supplement insurance required?

Are you curious whether you have to have supplemental insurance with Medicare? The answer is no, Medicare Supplement insurance is an add-on, just like Medicare Part D, which covers prescriptions.
“However, many individuals elect to add other supplemental coverage, such as Hospital Indemnity insurance, to their Original Medicare or Medicare Advantage plans to limit their out-of-pocket exposure to medical costs,” Bueltel says.

3. Do I need Medicare Supplement insurance?

Just like many healthcare coverage decisions, the answer to, “Do I need supplemental insurance with Medicare?” is a personal one. About one in three of Americans enroll in Medigap coverage, according to data from the Kaiser Family Foundation.
Here’s how Bueltel breaks this question down for clients: “Original Medicare has deductibles and copays built within Part A and Part B. If you do not want to be responsible for those deductibles and copays, add a Medicare Supplement policy to cover those costs.”

4. What does Medicare Supplement insurance cover?

As mentioned, it covers many copays, deductibles, and coinsurance. But does supplemental insurance cover routine physical exams, hospice, or hearing aids? Medicare may help with some of those charges, but Medicare Supplement policies do not usually cover dental, vision, hearing, long-term, and private-duty nursing care. They do cover hospice care.
In terms of Medico’s coverage, “as long as Medicare would pay for your medical services, Medico’s Medicare Supplement plan would cover services related to those conditions,” Bueltel explains.

5. Who pays first, Medicare or supplemental insurance?

Medicare Part A and B pay first, then Medicare Supplement insurance kicks in to help cover the gaps. Most healthcare providers have signed an agreement with Medicare to accept all Medicare-covered services and bill accordingly, but always check with your doctor or provider before receiving treatment if you’re unsure.

6. How do I shop for Medicare Supplement insurance?

There are four main steps to choose a Medicare Supplement insurance plan, according to the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services:

  1. Decide which benefits you want, then decide which of the Medicare Supplement plans A–N meet your needs.
  2. Find out which insurance companies sell Medicare Supplement policies in your state.
  3. Learn about the insurance companies that sell the policies you’re interested in and compare costs.
  4. Buy the Medicare Supplement policy.

Medicare Supplement plans come in A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M, and N, with varying amounts of costs and coverage, depending on the deductible level and specific plan. Premiums vary by state and plan, please contact an insurance agent to get a quote.

7. What is the difference between Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans?

“Medicare Supplements are supplemental plans designed to cover the remaining costs, like deductibles and copays generated from Original Medicare Part A and Part B. Medicare replacement insurance is another term for Medicare Advantage, and Medicare Advantage acts as the main payor regarding medical services received while insured under a Medicare Advantage plan. It replaces Original Medicare as the primary payor,” Bueltel says.

That means you cannot have Medicare Supplement insurance with Medicare Advantage plans.

Fill Medicare and Medicare Advantage Gaps with Hospital Indemnity Riders

8. Is Medicare Supplement insurance tax deductible?

Some premiums — including Medicare Part B and Part B supplemental insurance — are tax deductible through Schedule A on Form 1040. But they are only valid over a certain income threshold. If you’re self-employed, you may be able to deduct your supplemental Medicare insurance premiums as part of a self-employed health insurance deduction. Please contact a professional tax consultant for specific tax advice.

To learn how Medico’s Medicare Supplement insurance plan can help fill your coverage gaps and if it’s available in your state, visit the Medicare Supplement page. You may also request a personalized, free quote, or call 877-257-2663 to speak with an agent.

This content may contain links to third party websites, but Medico is neither responsible nor liable for their content, accuracy, or security. Review this website’s Terms and Conditions to learn more.

Photo credit: iStock

Affordable plans with quality built in

Medicare Supplement Insurance

Request a free quote

Call 877-257-2663 or click the button below to have an agent contact you to develop a personalized free quote for any of our insurance plans.

Get a Quote

Access your insurance information whenever you want

When you create accounts on Medico's secure customer portal website and mobile app, you can complete policy-related tasks when it’s convenient for you — safely and quickly.

Learn more

10 Best and Worst Diets for People Over 60

With new diet trends constantly emerging, it can be difficult to decide which diet plans to follow. Before you try any of these diets, learn which senior diet plans help weight loss, disease prevention, and overall health.

Read More

How to Choose Supplemental Health Insurance That’s Right for You

Deciding the best supplemental policy for your needs out of myriad of options can be difficult. Learn key insurance terms and how to use them to choose the right supplemental health insurance policy for your needs.

Read More

Answers to Your Most Common Questions About Telemedicine

Telemedicine not only limits transmitting viruses, like COVID-19, it also increases access to care.

Learn More

Why Seniors Need Dental, Vision, and Hearing Insurance

Vision, hearing, and dental insurance for seniors pairs well with Medicare, Medicare Supplement, and Medicare Advantage for more comprehensive health coverage.

Learn More

Answers to Frequently Asked Cancer Insurance Questions

Learn how First Diagnosis Cancer insurance helps cancer patients and their families steer clear of major financial hardships as the result of cancer treatment.

Read More

How to Find Senior Care That’s Right for You

If you’re weighing senior care options for yourself or a loved one, it’s important to learn what each type offers, which will work best for your situation, and what insurance will cover.

Read More

What Your Insurance Covers for Hip or Knee Replacement

If you’re a senior considering a knee replacement or hip replacement, your first concerns may be how much the procedure will cost, what your insurance will cover, and what you may have to pay out-of-pocket.

Read More

Don't Forget Healthcare and Insurance When Retirement Planning

It's easy to focus solely on saving, but don't forget to include healthcare and insurance in your retirement planning.

Read More

Health and Financial Milestones for Age 50 and Beyond

This age-by-age breakdown will help you know when to schedule health screenings, how to build up your savings, and prepare to live your best life during retirement.

Read More